Which 2 players is a better fit for my team?Option 1:1B- Ryan HowardSS- Carlos GuillenOption 2:SS- Jose Reyes1B- Justin MorneauC-Bengie Molina1B-???????2B- Brandon Phillips3B- David WrightSS-???? OF- Magglio OrdonezOF- Torii HunterOF- Hunter PenceUTIL- Aramis RamirezBN- Jim ThomeBN- Juan PierreBN- Rickie Weeks

no way that I would trade reyes and morneau for howard and guillen. no way.

Not at all

I would take Howard and Guillen because you dont have that much power

Option 2 by a LONG shot.

Option 2:Jose ReyesJustin MorneauMorneau is more than enough power added to your current lineup, Reyes is the key ingredient missing from your roster. With the likes of Reyes playing SS over Guillen, you would put a lock on all speed influenced categories.. Runs, Stolen Bases & On Base Percentage. I expect a better AVG. from Reyes in o8 as compared to his o7 numbers.Peace

You didn't say what your scoring system is - standard 5x5 roto? Or do you have other stats, like OPS, Hits, Doubles, etc. ?Based on the standard 5x5 - you would get a significant HR (20 projected HR's more) and RBI boost with Guillen and Howard but lose a lot of SB's - however, with Phillips, Hunter, Pierre and Weeks, you should be able to cover the SB's. It's a lot tougher to get power. I would take Howard and Guillen over Reyes and Morneau, and go for the pop.