View Full Version : Fantasy Baseball Trade Advice: Jose Reyes and Justin Morneau for Ryan Howard and Carlos Guillen?


Richie
02-24-2005, 12:44 PM
Which 2 players is a better fit for my team?Categories: AVG, R, HR, RBI, SB, OPSOption 1:1B- Ryan HowardSS- Carlos GuillenOption 2:SS- Jose Reyes1B- Justin MorneauMY TEAM:C-Bengie Molina1B-Ryan Howard2B- Brandon Phillips3B- David WrightSS- Jose GuillenOF- Magglio OrdonezOF- Torii HunterOF- Hunter PenceUTIL- Aramis RamirezBN- Jim ThomeBN- Juan PierreBN- Rickie Weeks

mrh_hoss
03-06-2005, 06:40 AM
Reyes will get you a lot of steals while Howard will rake for you.

cswing5
03-16-2005, 12:35 AM
I'd go with the deal that gives you Reyes. Getting a major stolen base threat is harder to get during the season through free agency than it is to find some power. You might not find a 50-home run guy, but you might can find a 40 home run guy down the road. Plus, you're pretty much assure yourself a first-place finish in the stolen base category.

redsoxfan5614950
03-25-2005, 06:30 PM
This is a really tough trade. You have a bunch of players who will help with homeruns and steals which is great. But, I think you need homeruns more than you need steals. On the other hand, I think you get better value in this trade. Reyes is taken ahead of Howard and Morneau is taken ahead of Guillen. Based on that, I would accept the trade.Hope I helped!