View Full Version : Is it appropriate to trading room cleaning with playing with a younger sibling with my 5 year old?


KellieW
05-10-2007, 05:09 AM
My kids are 5 1/2 and 3 1/2. They are homeschooled 3 days a week and go to school 2 days a week. I work at the school as an instructional aide. My point is that I spend tons of time with my kids; reading to them, playing with them, etc. My older child loves to play with things like LEGOs and Hot Wheels, which make a pretty big mess in his room. 10 minutes of play can create about an hour of mess for him to clean up.The kids help out with chores (cooking, dishes, tidying their rooms for 20 minutes, etc.). Is is appropriate that I ask my son if he would prefer to play with his sister or finish cleaning his room? I prefer the peace and quiet while cleaning, and the kids have more fun playing together. He always opts to play with his sister. They also have friends over to play with, and we do tons of stuff together.I think we all benefit, as my daughter has a fresh playmate, I get calm time, and he has a nice balance of chore time and sibling time. What do you think?Just wanted to clarify: My son does have to clean up after himself. He can't leave stuff lying around the house, and he is expected to spend at least 20 minutes a day cleaning his room. However, since we are home most of the day, and he loves to build LEGO stuff (which requires him to dump out many boxes to find the right peice) I'm OK with helping him tidy. He can't simply opt out of cleaning to play with his little sister. What I offer him is a "You clean your room for 20 minutes (and I tell him what I expect to be cleaned during that time), and if you will keep your sister busy (so I can clean not just his room, but the rest of the house), I'll do the rest." What takes me 15 minutes takes him 45. He is 5, after all. He does have responsibilities. He sorts and puts away his laundry, he unloads the dishwasher, sets the table, and cooks a mean steak (seriously). I'm not interested in raising a man who cannot care for himself! I just want a break from "My Little Ponys" occasionally.

Karen
05-15-2007, 04:40 PM
I think it is important for you son to clean up after himself! If you don't get him doing that now, you will be forever picking up his messes. Of course a kid would prefer to play rather than cleaning up his mess! I could see doing it for him once in a while, but not on a regular basis.

PatsyA
05-21-2007, 04:11 AM
It sounds like you're striking a good balance. Another option would be to set aside a corner of his room that he can just leave the mess until he's ready to move on to something else.

JESSICAS
05-26-2007, 03:43 PM
I THINK THAT IT IS VERY IMPORTANT FOR YOUR SON TO START LEARNING HOW TO ALWAYS CLEAN UP AFTER HIMSELF...IF HE DOESN'T HE IS ALWAYS GONNA RELIE ON YOU TO CLEAN HIS MESSES... I WOULD MAKE HIM CLEAN IT AND PLAY WITH HIS SISTER... MAYBE SHE CAN HELP HIM... IT WILL TEACH HER HOW TO CLEAN UP AFTER HERSELF AND EACH OTHER...

notmuchofacook
06-01-2007, 03:14 AM
What you are doing is allowing your son reasonable choices, and respecting his choices. You are teaching him that having a home involves responsibility that should be shared by all the residents. You are teaching him teamwork and that taking care of your responsibilities reaps its own rewards.Your younger child is learning by watching the two of you that communicating and working together is a win-win for everybody.Trust your instincts. It sounds like all is well at your house. Congratulations.